Is It Worth Using an Insurance Broker in Ireland?

Is it worth using an insurance broker in Ireland?

For most Irish consumers and small business owners, yes – using an insurance broker is worth it when you want choice, professional advice and someone in your corner at claims time. A broker searches a panel of insurers on your behalf, explains the cover in plain English and handles the paperwork. It is usually not the right choice if your needs are very simple, you enjoy shopping around yourself, or you already know exactly what you want.

What does an insurance broker actually do?

An insurance broker is a regulated intermediary who arranges cover between you and an insurer. Rather than working for one company, a broker works for you – assessing your needs and matching them to a suitable policy.

In Ireland, brokers are authorised and supervised by the Central Bank of Ireland and must follow the Consumer Protection Code. That means clear advice, fair treatment and transparency about how they are paid.

A good broker typically:

Reviews your situation and recommends suitable cover
Sources quotes from a panel of leading Irish insurers
Explains exclusions, excesses and policy terms in plain language
Helps you make changes mid-term (a new car, a business premises, an extra driver)
Supports you if you need to make a claim

How do insurance brokers get paid in Ireland?

Most brokers are paid a commission by the insurer when a policy is placed. Some also charge the customer a separate fee for arranging or administering cover, particularly for more complex business insurance.

Under Central Bank rules, an Irish broker must disclose how they are remunerated. You are entitled to ask, before you buy, whether a fee applies and how the broker is paid – and a reputable broker will tell you clearly.

Broker vs comparison site vs going direct: which is cheaper?

There is no single answer, and honesty matters here: no channel is automatically cheaper for everyone. Price depends on the insurer, your risk profile and how well the cover is matched to your needs.

A cheap headline price can cost you dearly if the policy has the wrong excess, missing cover or an exclusion you did not spot. The real question is not just “what is the price?” but “what am I actually covered for, and who helps me when something goes wrong?”

It is also worth knowing that several well-known Irish “comparison” websites are themselves brokers, quoting from their own panel rather than the whole market. Always check who you are actually dealing with and whether they are Central Bank regulated.

Option	Choice of insurers	Advice & claims help	Best for
Broker	Access to a panel of insurers, searched on your behalf	Personal advice and support through the claims process	People who want guidance, choice and help if a claim arises
Comparison website	Several insurers or brokers shown side by side (not always the whole market)	Limited – mostly self-service, little tailored advice	Confident buyers with straightforward, standard needs
Buying direct	One insurer only – the one you go to	Support from that insurer, but no independent advice	People loyal to a specific insurer who know what they want

What are the advantages of using a broker?

Choice without the legwork: the broker does the searching across multiple insurers for you.
Advice that fits you: useful for non-standard situations – modified cars, older homes, mixed business risks or a poor claims history.
Plain-English clarity: someone explains what is and is not covered before you commit.
A hand at claims time: arguably the biggest benefit, when you most need an advocate.
Continuity: a relationship that reviews your cover year after year, rather than starting from scratch each renewal.

When should you NOT use a broker?

Being balanced, a broker is not always the answer. You may be perfectly well served going direct or using a comparison tool if:

Your needs are simple and standard – for example basic cover with a clean record.
You genuinely enjoy researching and comparing quotes yourself.
You are loyal to one insurer and are happy with their direct pricing.
You want to buy instantly online at midnight without speaking to anyone.

The best channel is the one that matches how much choice, advice and support you actually want. Some people value a quick self-service purchase; others sleep better knowing a professional has checked the detail.

Are online brokers regulated in Ireland?

Yes. Whether a broker operates from a high-street office or entirely online, they must be authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland to arrange insurance. Regulation does not depend on the shopfront.

You can check a firm’s status on the Central Bank’s register. Bodies such as Insurance Ireland, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) and Citizens Information also publish helpful, impartial guidance for consumers.

Broker vs comparison site for business insurance

For small business owners, the case for a broker is often stronger. Business risks are rarely standard – a café, a tradesperson and an online retailer need very different cover, and a wrong assumption can leave a costly gap.

Comparison sites tend to handle simple personal lines well but struggle with the nuance of commercial cover. A broker can bundle liability, property, stock and other risks into a coherent programme. You can learn more on our business insurance page.

How do I choose the right insurance channel?

Ask yourself three questions: How complex is my situation? How much advice do I want? And who do I want in my corner if I have to claim? Your answers usually point clearly to a broker, a comparison site or buying direct.

If you want to explore your options, you can talk it through with Breeze Insurance on 0818 700 300 or request a quote online. For drivers, our car insurance page is a good place to start.

The bottom line

Using an insurance broker in Ireland is worth it when you value choice, tailored advice and real support at claims time – which is why many consumers and most small business owners lean towards one. If your needs are simple and you are happy to do the legwork, a comparison site or buying direct can serve you well. Whichever route you choose, make sure the firm is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland and that you understand exactly what your policy covers.

Frequently asked questions

Do insurance brokers charge a fee in Ireland?

Some do and some do not. Many brokers are paid commission by the insurer, while others also charge a separate fee, especially for complex cover. Under Central Bank rules, a broker must disclose how they are paid, so always ask before you buy.

Is a broker cheaper than going direct?

Not automatically. A broker can compare a panel of insurers to find suitable cover, but price depends on your circumstances and the insurer. The value often lies in getting the right cover and support, not just the lowest number.

Are online brokers regulated in Ireland?

Yes. Any firm arranging insurance in Ireland, online or in person, must be authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland and follow the Consumer Protection Code. You can verify a firm on the Central Bank’s register.

What is the difference between a broker and a comparison website?

A broker gives personal advice and helps with claims, drawing on a panel of insurers. A comparison website mainly lists prices for you to choose from with little tailored advice – and some Irish comparison sites are actually brokers quoting from their own panel.

Can a broker help me if I have a claim?

Yes, and this is one of the main reasons people use a broker. Your broker can guide you through the claims process, liaise with the insurer and act as your advocate when you most need support.

Do I still deal with the insurance company if I use a broker?

The insurer still underwrites and pays your claim, but the broker acts as your point of contact for advice, changes and support. Many people find it simpler to have one relationship rather than dealing with the insurer alone.

Breeze Insurance Ltd. is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland.

Cookie	Purpose of Cookie
Campaign	User campaign reference.
Url Referrer	User URL referrer.
Google analytics: _utma, _utmb, _utmc, _utmz	Used to anonymously track website use*.

	Initial Fee	Renewal Fee	Policy Alterations / Cancellation Fee
Motor	Up to a max of €230	Up to a max of €230	Up to a max of €90
Household	Up to a max of €230	Up to a max of €230	Up to a max of €90
Commercial	Up to a max of 25% of premium	Up to a max of 25% of premium	Up to a max of 25% of premium
Fees are calculated depending on the complexity of the product and the amount of time spent assisting the Client with the Services.

Director	€230 per hour
Consultant/Account Executive	€150 per hour
Qualified Financial Advisor	€110 per hour
Administration	€50

1.	Contact and Identifying information, e.g., name, address, contact details; email, mobile, landline
2.	Unique identifiers e.g. · PPS number – the reason why we collect your PPS number is to assist with providing services in connection with life insurance products that we sell whereby the insurer mandates the collection of such information, or otherwise. · pension scheme reference number- the reason why we collect this is for use when we sell life insurance related products · insurance policy numbers, the reason why we collect this is to be able to reference this policy is we need to communicate with agents or providers of existing policies you might have, given your consent.
3.	Demographic details, age, gender, marital status, lifestyle, and insurance requirements; date of birth, dependents, photo ID, as well as collecting personal information about you, we may also use personal information about other people, for example family members you wish to insure on a policy. E.g., your children/spouse
4.	Family and Beneficiary Data, e.g., dependants, next of kin or nominated beneficiaries, Power of Attorney, Enduring Power of Attorney. Details of Solicitor/Tax Advisor/Accountant.
5.	*Employment information* e.g., role, employment status (such as full/part time, contract), salary information, employment benefits, and employment history; This information is necessary for our Fact Find with our clients.
6.	Publicly available sources: e.g., Information about you in the public domain such as Director information from the Companies Registration Office.
7.	Health information such as information about your health status, medical records and medical assessment outcomes; We collect medical information relating to personal habits (e.g., smoking and consumption of alcohol), medical history. We may also process certain special categories of information, for example information about your personal characteristics (biometric information) or disability information. This information may be collected for the benefit of us proving insurances in the form of Life cover, health insurance, etc.
8.	Pensions and Insurance Benefits information such as current benefits, pension entitlement information, date of retirement and any relevant matters impacting your benefits such as voluntary contributions, PAO, etc.
9.	Financial details e.g., bank account details, details of your credit history and bankruptcy status, salary, tax code, third-party deductions, bonus payments, benefits and entitlement data, national insurance contributions details, etc.
10.	Claims Data (From you and any relevant third parties)
11.	*Marketing preferences*: we will only send you direct marketing if you explicitly consent, either through our website, by phone, email or written correspondence.
12.	Online information: e.g., information about your visits to our websites; please refer to our Cookies Notice at the footer of our webpage for further information.
13.	Events information e.g., information about your interest in and attendance at our events, including provision of feedback forms;
14.	Social media information (e.g., likes and posts) with our social media presence; this includes LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram
15.	Criminal records information e.g., the existence of or alleged criminal offences, or confirmation of clean criminal records for motor products.

1.	Performing services for our clients and prospective clients – when you require insurance/investment products, we use your data to enable us to provide the required product
2.	Statutory and other regulatory requirements – we are required to carry out various obligations which include: · AML/Sanction checking · Knowing your customer “Fact Find” · Adherence to the Consumer Protection Code
3.	Communicate and marketing to you – We do this by phone, through email, Google Ad services, Bing Ad services, Social Channels (LinkedIn, Facebook & Instagram).
4.	Process claims – We do this by gathering information relative to the claim by sending you our Claims Form and asking that you fill this in and return it to us for onward issue to the relevant insurer.
5.	To contact you if required or to respond to any communications that you might send to us.
6.	To administer our site including data analysis, testing, research, statistical and survey purposes.
7.	Carry out our obligations arising from any contracts entered between you and us and to provide you with the information, products and services that you request.
10	Handling complaints Please refer to a our Complaints Handling Procedure here for further details.
11	To notify you about changes to our services

1.	Insurance Partners where we need to manage the services provided to you such as Product Providers and insurance underwriters, reinsurers, and loss adjuster. You can refer to their privacy statements on their website for more information about their privacy practices.
2.	Vetting and risk management agencies such as credit reference, criminal record, fraud prevention, data validation and other professional advisory agencies, where necessary to prevent and detect fraud in the insurance industry and take steps to assess the risk in relation to prospective or existing insurance policies and/or the services.
3.	Legal advisers, loss adjusters, and claims investigators, where necessary to investigate, exercise or defend legal claims, insurance claims or other claims of a similar nature;
4.	Medical professionals, e.g., where you provide health information in connection with a claim against your insurance policy; or when we are providing a quote for insurance.
5.	EU Law enforcement bodies, when required to do so by law and/or regulation, or another legal request.
6.	Public authorities, regulators and government bodies, where necessary for us to comply with our legal and regulatory obligations, or in connection with an investigation of suspected or actual illegal activity;
7.	Third-party processors: We outsource our processing operations to suppliers that process personal information on our behalf. Examples include IT service providers who manage our IT and back-office systems and telecommunications networks, and accounting and payroll providers, CRM providers. These processing operations remain under our control and we have data processing agreements in place with all our third party processors to ensure all processing is carried out in accordance with our security standards and the GDPR.
8.	Internal and external auditors where necessary for the conduct of company audits or to investigate a complaint or security threat.
9.	On the sale or reorganisation of our business whether by asset or share disposal or other transaction relating to our business.

Is It Worth Using an Insurance Broker in Ireland?